If you’re not into manual labor, or if you’ve ever been irritated by trying to make frosting with a hand mixer, then a stand mixer is for you! Check out this informative and factual blog post comparing KitchenAids vs Hamilton Beach Stand Mixers.
For those of us who enjoy our kitchen time as much as we enjoy cooking in it, the pursuit of the perfect kitchen appliance has become near-obsessive. And with over 50 different stand mixers on the market to choose from, it can be hard to narrow down which one is right for your needs. We’re here to help!
With this article, we’ll compare the KitchenAid (KA) 5 Qt KSM150 Mixer against the Hamilton Beach 10-Speed Digital Stand Mixer (HB). Keep in mind, there are several different sizes of KitchenAid mixers – new momma’s have a smaller one called the 5.5 Qt KA5KM, and those with kids have a larger size called the 7.5 QT KA7KM – so you may need to read other comparison’s blog posts for that information.
This is a great comparison when it comes to price, power and reliability – we’ll start with power.
Both the KA and HB mixers have 325 Watts of Power – However…
The KitchenAid KSM150 has 10 Speeds, while the Hamilton Beach HB only has 5 Speeds – In other words, the KitchenAid is much more powerful. This means you can use it for mixing thicker recipes like cookie dough, bread dough and pizza dough. The HB mixer has 3 different speed options for the attachments (more on that later). It also means that if you’re new to stand mixers you might want to start with a lower speed (such as 4 or 5).
The KitchenAid Mixer is also LOUDER than the HB Mixer – In fact, most reviewers of both products agree that the KitchenAid is so loud they can’t use it while sitting in their living room. They suggest using ear plugs if you want to use it when people are nearby. The other option is to remove it to another room in your house (this is not hard with a removeable splash guard and cord).
The KitchenAid Mixer has fewer attachments than the Hamilton Beach Mixer – The KitchenAid KSM150 comes with a whisk, beater, dough hook, flat beater, wire whip and a pasta whip. The Hamilton Beach comes with a whisk, beater, dough hook, flat beater and a wire whip.
There are more attachments available for the HB stand mixer – It comes with three different beaters that you can attach to it (one flat whisk attachment; one rolling pin; one wire whip) as well as an optional bowl scraper. On the Hamilton Beach website they suggest washing all attachments in hot water to disinfect them before you use them (wash with dish soap and rinse), but again…all of these attachments are available for the KitchenAid mixer.
The HB stand mixer has a slightly different flat beater that is longer and thinner. The flat beater is designed to scrape the sides of the bowl while mixing and can also be used to mix cake batter or do kneading (if you don’t have a bread hook).
Both mixers come with a storage case – they’re both extra durable and made to store your mixer when not in use. The HB case actually has little wheels – this makes it easier to move around when full (the KitchenAid case must be lifted with handles).
How Good Is The Hamilton Beach Stand Mixer?
It’s apparently a very good stand mixer – the kitchen experts at Consumer Reports rated the Hamilton Beach Mixer as the best mixer for under $100. That’s with over 50,000 reviews, which is more than any other mixer on the market! When you look at their ratings for stand mixers, it ranges from 5 out of 5 stars to 2.6 out of 5 stars. The Hamilton Beach stand mixer received an overall score of 4.6 out of 5 stars.
So, how does the Hamilton Beach stand mixer compare to the KitchenAid Mixer? On Price and Power – it’s very comparable. The Hamilton Beach HB Digital Stand Mixer is priced from $78 to $99 depending on the model you get. The KitchenAid KSM150 comes in several price ranges, from $220 all the way up to almost $400, depending on if you want a Special Edition or Professional Series.
The KitchenAid also has a bigger motor and more power than the HB – this means it can mix thicker recipes easier, as we mentioned before (like cookie dough, bread dough and pizza dough).
Are Hamilton Beach Beaters Interchangeable?
The KitchenAid Beater allows you to attach almost any type of beater that is made by KitchenAid. If you have a KitchenAid mixer and need a new beaters, do a search on the Hamilton Beach website and see if the ones you need are available.
The Hamilton Beach Beater allows you to attach most types of beaters – it doesn’t specify though, so if you don’t find the one that works for your recipes, just ask them before buying!
Who Do I Recommend This For?
This is a very personal decision. Some people will want to go for the best mixer on the market because it’s powerful and has more accessories…but if you’re only mixing small batches of things like cookies, cakes, muffins and pancakes all the time, then a 4qt KitchenAid is probably good enough.
If you’re looking for an affordable stand mixer for kids – then it’s hard to beat the Hamilton Beach. There are plenty of options on Amazon for kids in several different price ranges. Plus, it has so many attachments, they’ll be able to use it all their life and save money!
When Was The Hamilton Beach Model G Mixer Made?
The Hamilton Beach brand started making the G mixer in 2005. In the beginning, it was only made in red color, but later on they added other colors as well.
The KitchenAid model KSM150 Mixer was made by KitchenAid from 1956 to present (as of this writing). This is the oldest model of KitchenAid mixers and it has been tested and approved by Amway Corporation for over 50 years!
When Did Hamilton Beach Come Out?
The Hamilton Beach Company was founded in 1921 by Carl Crane, and they started to make appliances in the 1930’s (20 years before KitchenAid started making mixers). In 1978 they created the first stand mixer that could be used with one hand.
How Many Colors Are Available For The Hamilton Beach Mixer?
Currently, this mixer is available in five different colors: White, Red, Yellow, Blue and Pink. When you visit the Hamilton Beach Website you can click on the link that says “Color” and it will show you the five colors for each model (such as the beater), plus which come with a dough hook – or not.
Do The Hamilton Beach Stand Mixers Have a Warranty?
Hamilton Beach has a very good warranty – their stand mixer comes with a 3 year limited warranty. They honor it for US and Canada. If your Product has any defects, they will either repair or replace it at no cost.
Do KitchenAid attachments work on Hamilton Beach?
The KitchenAid attachments work on the Hamilton Beach stand mixer (if you buy the same attachments). The only differences are:
KSM150 Stand Mixer – This mixer has a plastic beater and a metal dough hook. It does not have a wire whip or whisk (which the HB has) and it comes with only one flat beater attachment. The HB mixer also comes with a bowl scraper attachment, which is optional on the KSM150.
What Are The Reasons To Choose The Hamilton Beach Mixer Over The KitchenAid?
Battery operated, so you can use it anywhere. It’s easy to clean and there are no plastic gears and parts. Comes with 56 different attachments – more than the KitchenAid mixer. One of the most affordable mixers out there, though there are more expensive models available.
Hamilton Beach really has been a pioneer in the kitchen since 1921, and they are continuing to innovate in 2015. They are a great option for people who have limited space or need things that can be easily packed up! Their products don’t take up a lot of space, and their stand mixers are battery operated (so you don’t have to worry about cords getting in your way!).
Many of the attachments for KitchenAid mixers will also fit Hamilton Beach mixers – so if you want to buy an attachment from Hamilton Beach and it’s not available, just look at what KitchenAid has to offer.
I hope this review on the best Hamilton Beach stand mixer helped you decide which model is right for you.