Bread Maker Or Stand Mixer-Which One To Choose

What is the difference between a bread maker and a stand mixer? Which one should I choose?

In this article, we will compare and contrast bread makers vs. stand mixers. We will also provide a buying guide to help you make the best choice for your needs.

Bread makers are usually compact, easy-to-use appliances which allow you to create fresh loaves of bread at home with minimal effort. They make the process simple as you only have to insert the ingredients in a single container, set the timer and wait for your freshly baked loaf.

Stand mixers, on the other hand, are large appliances which are typically used by professional chefs and bakers. Despite their size, they can handle heavy mixing jobs far better than bread makers.

Today we will review all the relevant technical aspects of both these products in order to help you determine which one will be more useful to you. We will also look at some of their pros and cons so that you can really understand what each one is all about.

Let’s begin with the simple and most basic description of each appliance:

Bread makers work by mixing yeast, water and flour together to create a dough. This process is very similar to traditional baking where the ingredients are combined in a bowl, covered with plastic wrap, placed into an oven and baked. The main difference with bread makers is that they use their own built-in timers to turn on their motors after the pre-set time indicated on the appliance’s front panel has elapsed. This allows the machine to mix the dough all by itself while you can relax and do other things.

Because of their simple design, bread makers do not have all the additional accessories which are normally expected in a kitchen appliance. They only have basic kneading paddles and a lid with an ingredient dispenser which you can use to add more bread flour if you wish to make the dough thicker.

The other type of bread making appliance is the much more complex stand mixer . These appliances use their powerful motors to mix the ingredients and knead them in order to create dough. They also come with various attachments that can help you accomplish several tasks in your kitchen, such as making egg wash, whipping cream and slicing vegetables and fruits into julienne strips.

See also  To Buy Or Not To Buy: The KitchenAid Mixer

“It never fails- we have a new appreciation for fresh baked bread when winter rolls around. Suddenly, all we want to eat is flavorful sourdough and hearty whole grain loaves slathered in butter. But how do you go about making crusty bread at home? Do you even bake your own bread? In this post, we’re going to explore the options available for those of you who want to make it at home but don’t (or can’t) bake it yourself.”

This post will explore the pros and cons of each type of machine and let readers know when they might want one or the other.

The obvious decision as to which machine is most appropriate for you would have to be based on your own preference and the kind of bread you like best. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons associated with each type of machine.

If traditional sourdough loaves, whole grain breads, and hearty artisan loaves are your preference then the countertop machines such as the Kenwood or Panasonic are solid choices. But if you like white bread as well then these machines may not be for you. If this is the case, I encourage you to consider a stand mixer instead. But if you like authentic artisan breads and whole grain breads then these machines are a perfect match.

If, on the other hand, you like all sorts of white and whole wheat varieties as well as milder European peasant loaves then I would encourage you to consider the stand mixer instead. This can be a great way to get started with baking your own bread at home, and is much more versatile than a countertop machine. It’s also less expensive overall than the countertop machines so it could save you money over time.

Which is best for me?

Well, if I had to choose one or the other. Both machines are great in their own way. So what would I do? For me, this is a toss-up between the countertop machine or the stand mixer. I like the simplicity and ease of use of either machine. In the end, it is a matter of personal preference and working with what you have at your disposal.

See also  Bosch Mixer Vs Kitchen Aid: Which Mixer Is Right For You? Let’s Find Out!

Of course, if you have the extra cash to throw around on a new machine then go for it. But frankly I don’t think that any customer would be able to tell which type of bread making machine would be best for them based on reading this little article alone. If you’re still unsure about which one to choose then please take some time to check on both types of machines before making your decision.

Is bread machine better than stand mixer?

Those with sparse kitchens will be able to get away with a breadmaker, but for those of you with big kitchens and lots of counter space, a stand mixer is a better choice. You can fit more ingredients in one bowl, or use the mixing attachment to mix holiday doughs and fruit breads. Bread makers require the use of bread flour , which is typically cheaper than higher quality wheat flour . However, some bakers do prefer the way that wheat flour works when used in a bread maker. Some people say they prefer it to make them feel “more complete,” while others say that it makes their bread taste better.

Some wheat baking enthusiasts find that they like the taste of whole grain flour in their loaves. Bread making with any kind of whole wheat flour is difficult in a bread maker. For this reason, some people prefer stand mixers if they want to make whole wheat or whole rye loaves. Bread makers typically require the use of fresh yeast to work properly, even in the models that are activated by adding time and warmth. This is why it is difficult for them to make artisan or sourdough loaves. Some models do have the capability of producing artisan and sourdough loaves with yeast activated through higher internal heat settings. But like several other features on these machines, these features can vary from one model to another.

Can I use a bread maker as a mixer?

You can use a bread machine as a mixer, but it is not recommended. You must also keep in mind that each model is different in design, so you may or may not get good results with your first attempt. The reason that most manufacturers do not suggest mixing in the bread machine is because it has a motor that will have to work harder to mix in ingredients than one that was specifically designed to do so. This can cause the motor to burn out before its time, which will cause an early and unnecessary replacement.

See also  How Long Can You Keep Vanilla Extract? A Guide to Storage and Shelf Life

Is it worth it to have a bread maker?

The benefits of having a breadmaker are numerous, but it is up to you as the consumer to decide if it is a tool that you will use often enough to justify the expense. For example, some people choose to make their own bread because they want to avoid additives found in store-bought loaves. However, if you are making your own bread primarily for cost savings, then this may not be the best choice for you. You must also keep in mind that making your own bread will take longer than running out to the grocery store and purchasing some wheat slices.

Which mixer is good for bread?

Bread machines make quick and easy work of making bread, but you can substitute most any ordinary kitchen appliance for a standing mixer. A KitchenAid mixer is a good choice because it has several attachments that can help make your breads. If you are looking for a sturdy model, consider the Cuisinart CSB-75 Smart Stick model. Some people also like using their stand mixer to perform other jobs around the house. For example, people cook in their stand mixers a lot more than they do in their breadmakers, so using it as an extra oven really cuts down on cooking time.


Making bread by hand is time consuming. It involves measuring ingredients, kneading the dough and waiting for it to rise before slicing it into pieces and baking it. If you like to make bread using this traditional method, then you have little choice but to do so. For those who do not like making bread by hand, they have the option to use a manual bread making machine or a stand mixer. Manual machines are easy to use and make the process of making bread much quicker than doing the steps manually. However, you may want to wait for your market or supermarket near you sell them cheaper after a few months of their arrivals.