Bread Machine Vs. Stand Mixer: Which Is Right For Me?

Want to make a delicious, frothy loaf of bread but afraid of overcomplicating things? Then a stand mixer might be the perfect option for you. Let’s take a look at these two appliances known for their powerful capabilities and see which is best suited to your baking needs.

## Why use a stand mixer over a bread machine? ##

Because dough hooks work as an additional ingredient in dough that helps it rise, preventing the dough from becoming dry and dense. The continuous kneading action ensures full gluten development leading to consistently light, airy results. | The intense movement of whiskers around the blades helps aerate dough, creating light textures with air pockets inside (especially important when making loaves). | By constantly adding ingredients in the same order, a stand mixer can develop gluten evenly throughout the dough. |

The average price of a stand mixer is $100 compared to that of a bread machine which can cost $40-$1,000 depending on the brand, size and features. If your main focus is to knead dough and make bread from scratch, a stand mixer will definitely be your better option.

## Key Features ##

A dual-drive system with 10 speeds allows for precise mixing and blending action for wet or dry baking ingredients. The wide range of motion makes it ideal for mixing sauces and cookie batter as well. |

High-quality stainless steel mixing bowl with a BPA-free plastic insert and non-skid base. |

Rubber coating on the kneading blades, mixing shaft and on shaft of the beater. |

Wire whip that can be used to aerate batters, make light and fluffy meringues or beat egg whites. |

A short dough hook (1.5 inches) which extends out further than standard bread machine models allowing for more efficient use of ingredients in bread recipes. |

The base of the machine is heavy and sturdy enough to minimize the risk of tipping over. |

On-board storage for the wire whip, flat beater, dough hook and splash guard. |

## Key Features ##

Large capacity (1.5-1.65 lbs) that allows you to mix wet or dry ingredients, knead dough and bake a loaf of bread all at once. | The timer helps you track how long your machine has been mixing your ingredients as well as how long it has been kneading your dough (which can be up to 3 hours). | A large viewing window allows you to see inside the bowl during mixing so you know exactly what’s happening inside the machine. |

“Add ingredients” function allows the machine to pour ingredients into the bowl for you, helping you save time and hassle. | “Pre-programmed settings” are available for standard recipes like cakes and biscuits. Simply follow the on-screen instructions and let the machine take care of all the kneading and rising for you. Pans that fit specific machines also come with a non-stick coating. |

See also  KitchenAid Pro Vs. KitchenAid Artisan

Automatic dispensers consistently add ingredients like sugars, leavening agents or grains at regular intervals so that they are evenly distributed throughout your dough. | A scraper which scrapes the side of your mixing bowl ensuring that no dough is left stuck to it allowing for a smoother final product. |

Heavy-duty, non-stick Teflon bowl and non-slip grip for hands free mixing. | Self-cleaning and dishwasher safe. |

## Pros and Cons ##

This machine is easy to use with a number of different settings for kneading and mixing of wet or dry ingredients. It is also easy to clean – the parts can be removed for thorough cleaning, so the machine will last a long time without much maintenance. However, the bread maker tends to make your bread dense and heavy whereas the mixer produces light and airy results. We recommend using this type of product when you are making soft pastries like cakes and cookies since it will deliver consistent results every time.

A stand mixer is a good choice for those who want to make bread, cakes, pancakes and other pastries. The stand mixer can be easily customized to the texture and consistency of the dough you are making. For example, if your recipe calls for water and you do not have any on hand, you can add more flour in place of it. Additionally, the machine enables you to control the texture of your products while also ensuring that they are fully mixed and aerated.

However, we would not recommend this product to those who are just starting out with baking or cooking. This will help you to achieve a more consistent product every time, without fail. Also, if you are not careful with the machine, it can accidentally throw ingredients into the bowl. This can result in a mess and waste of money.

## Who Should Purchase It? ##

If you are just starting out with baking or cooking, we would recommend getting a stand mixer instead of a bread machine. If you make new recipes frequently, the bread maker will provide similarly consistent results every time. Instead, we recommend that you invest in a quality stand mixer and don’t worry about including it in your shopping list when you go to the store. Start out slow using the machine for simple baking projects like muffins. Once you are comfortable with it, you can easily purchase the more advanced version of the product from the same manufacturer to make more advanced cakes and pastries.

See also  KitchenAid Stand Mixer Review: Artisan Vs. Professional 600

## Buying Guide ##

As far as we know, there are only two brands in this category: KitchenAid 1.5 Quart Stand Mixer with Dough Hook Attachment, and Kenmore Elite 1.5 quart Stand Mixer with Extra-Large Dough Hook, Model # 33950. The machine is also known as KSM150PSOB and KM33950OB respectively. Both machines are available at very similar prices. We would recommend that you choose the brand with the higher rating by BHG.

Most buyers of this product have given it positive reviews, citing that it is good quality and they are happy with the value they received for their money. One thing to keep in mind when purchasing a machine, however, is that some buyers have experienced issues with parts breaking down over time as well as mixing dough yielding extremely sticky results. The parts also tend to be quite delicate, especially the mixing blades and bowl, which can break if you aren’t careful with using them.

Can I use a bread machine as a mixer?

A bread machine can be used as a mixer for certain types of doughs. The core function of a bread machine is to mix ingredients together and then allow them to rise. The depression at the bottom of the machine is specifically designed to make this process easier. For example, if you are using it to mix dry ingredients (flour, sugar, etc.), your recipe should say when it is time to add the liquid (water or milk). This will also ensure that no dry ingredients remain stuck in the depression as they would with a stand mixer. However, this does not apply if you are making a cake or cookie where you are mixing wet and dry ingredients together.

Is it better to make bread in a bread machine?

Bread machines are made to make bread from scratch. They will give you consistent results every time. The machine can be used with a variety of ingredients, unlike the stand mixer which will only mix wet and dry ingredients separately and then combine them together at the end. However, if you are using a recipe that requires kneading, it is still better to use a stand mixer. Another downside is that once the cycle has finished, you can’t add any additional ingredients or change anything else on the recipe without restarting the machine from scratch.

See also  KitchenAid Commercial vs. Globe vs. Hobart: Which Mixer?

Is KitchenAid good for making bread?

KitchenAid is a reputable brand name you can trust. We would recommend the brand in this category for beginners who are purchasing their first machine for the kitchen. It will help you to get started with baking and cooking and make sure that you are comfortable with how the machine works.

How do I use my bread machine?

Your bread machine will come with a recipe book as well as a manual which contains basic instructions on how to make bread. The book will also provide detailed instructions on how to operate the machine and troubleshoot when your dough becomes too dry, sticky or dense. If you are having problems with your recipe, we recommend that you contact a customer service representative for troubleshooting tips.

Should I make bread in a bread machine?

If you want a consistent, quality product every time and are fine with not having any control over the texture of the final product, we would recommend using a bread machine. It is also useful for those who have a busy schedule and don’t have time to bake from scratch.

How much does the average bread maker cost?

The price of this product varies considerably. Most of the machines are under $50, but some models are over $100 as well. You should keep an eye out for sales since they usually occur at least once per year (usually around Black Friday). We also tend to see deals on Amazon Prime Day and Cyber Monday.


Bread machines are convenient and easy to use. They are also a cheaper option compared to buying rolls, breads, and other baked goods from the store. As long as you are careful with the machine, it will make you a consistent product. It can also be used to mix dough into pizza dough or muffins without worrying about overmixing them. The prices vary widely and range between $20-100 depending on various factors such as brand name and model number. We would recommend going for a less expensive model if you are just starting out with cooking or baking since your first few products may not turn out very well (unless you have experience in this area).