,

Types of Vanilla: Imitation Vanilla Flavor vs. Extract

Vanilla is one of the most prized and widely used flavors in any bakery or commercial kitchen. But where does it come from, and what types of vanilla are the best to use? We’ll provide a guide to this popular ingredient and help you choose the right vanilla for your recipe.

Vanilla flavoring comes from vanilla orchids. These vanilla flowers are grown in different regions, and each type of orchid produces a vanilla bean with unique characteristics. Below are four of the most commonly used vanilla beans:

 Madagascar Vanilla Beans – Madagascar vanilla beans, also called Bourbon vanilla beans, are the most popular type of bean in the world and have a strong, creamy flavor.

 Mexican Vanilla Beans – Mexican vanilla beans are considered some of the best beans in the world, and they have a smooth, smoky vanilla flavor with a hint of spice.

 Tahitian Vanilla Beans – Tahitian vanilla beans have a unique floral flavor with notes of cherry and licorice. Among the most expensive types of vanilla, Tahitian beans are almost twice the size of other vanilla beans.

 Ugandan Vanilla Beans – Ugandan vanilla beans are not as well known, but they contain high amounts of natural vanillin, which gives them a bold flavor and aroma.

What Is Vanilla

Vanilla flavor comes from the dried seed pod of the vanilla orchid. Harvesting vanilla seed pods is a delicate, labor-intensive process that begins with the hand-pollination of the flower. Once pollinated, the flower produces a cluster of long, green bean pods. It takes several months for the pods to mature and even longer for the drying process to be complete. The fully matured, dried pod is what many would recognize as a dark-brown vanilla bean.

What Is Vanillin

Vanillin is the name of a naturally occurring organic compound that contributes to the flavor of vanilla beans. Mostly when the term vanillin is used, it refers to the synthetic version of the flavor compound. Manufacturers discovered they could create an artificial version of vanilla flavor by synthesizing the vanillin compound in a lab.

Imitation Vanilla vs Vanilla Extract

Pure vanilla extract contains natural vanillin, and imitation vanilla is made from synthetic vanillin. Natural vanilla flavor also contains hundreds of flavor compounds besides vanillin, but imitation vanilla flavoring gets its flavor from vanillin alone. This explains why natural vanilla has a more complex flavor and why artificial vanilla may lack depth.

Types of Vanilla Products

Many recipes just aren’t complete without vanilla flavoring. If you’ve ever wondered which type of vanilla product you should use, check out our guide below:

1. Vanilla Bean

Vanilla beans are the most expensive form of vanilla flavor, which is why many bakers end up using the more affordable extracts or flavorings. Splurging on real vanilla beans can elevate your desserts to a new level, not just by adding depth of flavor, but also by adding appealing flecks of brown from the vanilla seeds. Most fans of vanilla know when they see vanilla bean seeds in a product, it indicates a higher quality. Use vanilla beans when you want to create a show-stopping dessert for a special occasion.

To use vanilla bean, cut the ends off the bean pod and split it lengthwise to reveal thousands of tiny brown seeds bursting with vanilla flavor. Scrape out the seeds and add them to ice cream, custards, or light-colored buttercreams that show off the brown seeds. Keep in mind that high temperatures can degrade all the complex flavors of vanilla bean seeds, so save this special ingredient for uncooked or lightly simmered items.

See also  Are KitchenAid Stand Mixers Worth The Money

Vanilla Bean Form – Small, dark brown seeds and pulp

Vanilla Bean Flavor – Highly concentrated, complex vanilla flavor

Best Uses for Vanilla Bean – Artisan-quality desserts, delicate items cooked with low heat, homemade vanilla extract

Vanilla Bean Substitutes – Use 1 tablespoon of vanilla extract or 1 tablespoon of vanilla bean paste in place of 1 vanilla bean

2. Vanilla Bean Paste

Vanilla bean paste is made from the scraped seeds of a vanilla bean suspended in a thick extract. Next to the real vanilla bean, vanilla paste contains the most concentrated flavor. It also provides the same visual effect as a vanilla bean, with flecks of brown seeds appearing throughout your batters or custards.

The benefits of vanilla bean paste are that it provides a strong flavor and contains actual seeds but doesn’t require the same preparation as the bean. It’s more affordable than vanilla beans and more concentrated than vanilla extract, making it a happy medium between the two. Vanilla bean paste also contains less liquid than vanilla extracts, so it won’t water down your recipes.

Vanilla Bean Paste Form – Thick, jelly-like paste with flecks of brown seeds

Vanilla Bean Paste Flavor – Rich, smooth vanilla flavor

Best Uses for Vanilla Bean Paste – Puddings, custards, ice cream, light-colored cakes or frostings

Vanilla Bean Paste Substitutes – Use 1 tablespoon of vanilla extract or 1 vanilla bean for every 1 tablespoon of vanilla bean paste

3. Pure Vanilla Extract

Pure vanilla extract is made by soaking ground vanilla beans in a solution of alcohol and water. For the product to be labeled “pure”, it must contain 13.35% vanilla bean solids and 35% alcohol. Some vanilla extract products contain sugar or corn syrup to enhance the flavor of low-quality vanilla beans. Look for pure vanilla extract that contains only vanilla bean, alcohol, and water for a better quality product that will become more complex with age.

Because vanilla extract is more affordable than vanilla beans or vanilla paste, it’s useful in high-volume baking applications. Its thin liquid form can also be blended more evenly throughout cookie dough and cake batters to provide consistent flavor. When baking dark-colored treats like brownies, vanilla extract is the logical choice. Vanilla bean seeds will not be visible in these products, so it doesn’t make sense to splurge on beans or paste.

Pure Vanilla Extract Form – Thin, brown liquid

Pure Vanilla Extract Flavor – Smooth, mellow vanilla flavor

Best Uses for Pure Vanilla Extract – Cookies, brownies, cakes, muffins, frostings, sauces

Pure Vanilla Extract Substitutes – Use 1 tablespoon of vanilla bean paste or 1 vanilla bean for every 1 tablespoon of vanilla extract

4. Imitation Vanilla

Imitation vanilla is made from synthetic vanillin, one of the flavor compounds that gives natural vanilla its flavor. Because artificial vanilla only contains one flavor compound, it lacks the complex, nuanced flavors of real vanilla. However, imitation vanilla does have some benefits in the kitchen.

Vanilla beans, paste, and extracts have more depth of flavor than imitation vanilla, but many of those flavor notes degrade at the high temperatures used during baking. For this reason, imitation vanilla is preferred by some bakers for cookies and cakes. Strong vanilla flavor comes through after baking and usually cannot be distinguished from the real thing.

See also  Does Vanilla Extract Go Bad

Imitation Vanilla Form – Thin liquid, may be brown or clear

Imitation Vanilla Flavor – Slightly bitter out of the bottle, strong one-note vanilla flavor in baked goods

Best Uses for Imitation Vanilla – Cookies and cakes

Imitation Vanilla Substitutes – Use 1 tablespoon of vanilla extract for every 2 tablespoons of imitation vanilla

5. Vanilla Powder

Vanilla powder is made from dried, ground vanilla beans. The pure form of vanilla powder contains no fillers and should be light brown to dark brown in color. If the vanilla powder is white, it contains sugar or maltodextrin and has different uses. For rich, concentrated vanilla flavor, look for the pure vanilla powder.

Because vanilla powder contains no liquids, it can be added to buttercreams or batters without watering down the recipe. It also has an intense flavor that doesn’t degrade or burn off at high temperatures. The downside of vanilla powder? It’s just as expensive as vanilla beans.

Vanilla Powder Form – Dry, brown powder

Vanilla Powder Flavor – Rich, complex vanilla flavor

Best Uses for Vanilla Powder – Desserts that require a balanced ratio of liquid and dry ingredients, baked goods cooked at high temperatures, dry mixes

Vanilla Powder Substitutes – 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla powder is equal to 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract, 1 teaspoon of vanilla paste, or a 2″ section of vanilla bean

6. Vanilla Syrup

Vanilla syrup is a thick, sweet liquid made from sugar, water, and vanilla extract. Use vanilla flavoring syrup to sweeten beverages and desserts and add a touch of vanilla flavor. Most vanilla syrups are packaged in large bottles with a pump dispenser that makes it easy to add syrup to coffee drinks and cocktails.

Not suited for baking applications, vanilla syrup is the best product to use for cocktails, smoothies, and signature coffee drinks. The sweet syrup dissolves easily in beverages and can be combined with other syrups to create unique flavor combinations.

Vanilla Syrup Form – Thick, syrup-like liquid

Vanilla Syrup Flavor – Sugary with sweet vanilla flavor

Best Uses for Vanilla Syrup – Smoothies, cocktails, coffee drinks, flavored sodas, egg creams

Vanilla Syrup Substitutes – Add 3 teaspoons of vanilla extract to 1 cup of simple syrup to make your own vanilla syrup

Each vanilla product has advantages that make it useful in different applications. Vanilla beans are expensive but may be the gourmet ingredient you need to create delicate custards and luscious creams. Vanilla extract is an all-around, versatile ingredient that many bakers keep on hand for their recipes. But don’t count out imitation vanilla! It’s affordable and actually adds more flavor to baked goods cooked at high temperatures.

Does Vanilla Come From Beavers?

The vanilla extract in your baking products and extracts most likely does not come from beavers. It’s possible to source a vanilla flavor compound (castoreum) from beaver castor sacs, but this is a costly, labor-intensive process. If you want to be sure that you aren’t using castoreum, check the ingredients on your vanilla products. You are in the clear if you see vanilla beans, vanilla extracts, or artificial flavor (synthetic vanillin) listed.

See also  Vanilla Extract for Toothache: Can Vanilla Help Tooth Pain?

Where Do Vanilla Beans Come From?

Most of the vanilla beans sold commercially are harvested from vanilla orchids grown in Madagascar, Mexico, and Tahiti. There are vanilla orchids grown in other regions, but they are not as widely distributed.

How Much Imitation Vanilla Equals Vanilla Extract?

For most products, it takes twice as much imitation vanilla to equal vanilla extract. Use 2 teaspoons of imitation vanilla in place of 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract.

How Long Does Vanilla Last?

Pure vanilla extract with no additives will last indefinitely if it is stored in a cool, dark place. It will even develop more complex flavors over time. Imitation vanilla may start to lose its potency after 4 years.

Is Vanilla Extract Alcoholic?

Yes, pure vanilla extract contains at least 35% alcohol. Most of the alcohol burns off in the baking process and cannot be detected in the finished product. If you prefer to use an alcohol-free product, substitute 2″ of a vanilla bean or 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla bean powder for 1 teaspoon of pure vanilla extract.

Which is better vanilla extract or vanilla flavoring?

Vanilla extract is made from the seeds of vanilla beans. The process of making vanilla extract typically begins by drying beans over a fire. After the beans are dried, the process begins again by grinding them into a powder. The next step is to add alcohol to the mixture and then boil it for several hours, until all the alcohol is evaporated. Finally, vanilla extract can be filtered and packaged in bottles or tubes for storage.

Vanilla flavoring is made from vanillin and dehydrated materials such as cocoa butter. Vanilla flavor is added at a low temperature so that most of the raw flavors don’t disappear during processing.

Which is better extract or flavoring?

Vanilla extract is made by drying the vanilla bean. How it tastes depends on the type of bean used, how much natural sugar is on the bean, and how long it’s left to dry. There are many different types of vanilla beans and they all produce different flavors when dried. A popular variety of vanilla beans are Madagascar Criollo beans that are grown in Mexico. This type produces a more complex flavor with hints of cinnamon and clove in the dessert or icing recipe.

Flavored extracts usually have a broad range of vanillin blended with other flavors that have been dehydrated at low heat, giving them a very intense flavor in the finished product (many times more so than pure vanilla).

Can I replace vanilla extract with vanilla flavor?

You can replace vanilla extract with vanilla flavoring in a 1:1 ratio for certain applications. But for most recipes, using extract will give you a richer and more rounded flavor that also helps maintain moisture in the finished product.

How do I make homemade extracts?

It’s easy to make your own homemade vanilla extract. This project is a great “green” solution because it saves the beans from being wasted and the alcohol from being dumped down the drain. You can also create other flavors, such as cherry or orange extract that infuse into your desserts for an interesting flavor twist.

Vanilla extract is an all-around, versatile ingredient that many bakers keep on hand for their recipes. You can add it to a number of baked goods from cake to frosting and beverages from coffee drinks to smoothies using a pump bottle or add it to well-rounded cakes. Vanilla extract is especially useful in baking because the flavor is enhanced with baking and improves with age. A quality vanilla extract may be expensive at more than $10 per bottle, but its uses far outweigh the price of the product.