Substitute for Vanilla Extract in Cookies

Vanilla extract is an essential ingredient in many baking recipes, but if you don’t have any on hand or it’s not your favorite booze of choice, here’s a quick and easy recipe for vanilla sugar. It might not taste exactly like the real thing, but it’ll do the job just fine. If you’re feeling ambitious, why not try making your own vanilla extract?

The next time you’re short on cash, there are other alternatives to expensive extracts and flavorings — here’s how to make your own.

Tips & Techniques Substitute equal amounts of vanilla sugar for vanilla extract in a recipe. One teaspoon of vanilla sugar = 1/4 teaspoon of extract. Homemade vanilla extract can be used for longer than store-bought extracts. After six months, it will have lost some of its potency, but not all of its flavor.

The most popular uses for this homemade ingredient are in cookies and cakes, but you can use it in anything that calls for regular old vanilla extract. This simple swap can even save a step when making your favorite alcohol-based desserts!

Thankful Mamas shares recipes and ideas that engage families to make memories together across all seasons.  Her new book,  Recipes for the Holidays: Holiday Desserts from Start to Finish, is available now and can be purchased from Amazon.com (print version) .  Amazon Kindle and Kindle Fire users can download a FREE app to read on their devices by visiting amazon.com or searching ‘Thankful Mamas’ on the Amazon Appstore.

Vanilla extract is a simple but vital flavoring agent in baked goods and desserts. Pure vanilla is extracted from tropical vanilla pods, also known as the tropical vanilla planifolia. These magic pods are responsible for the rich flavor of the liquid flavoring. Many of the baked goods and delicious recipes we all enjoy contain vanilla extract. The flavor-enhancing aroma can not be missed.

Also, Apart from the sweet sensational aroma, vanilla extract has a lot of health benefits such as providing antioxidant effects, benefitting brain health, providing antiinflammatories properties, and so on. The taste of your cookies can never be the same without the presence of vanilla extract; without it, the outcome would be a flat and bland taste.

There are so many reasons you might want to look for substitutes for vanilla extract in your cookies. For example, you might prefer an alcohol-free option, as vanilla extract contains at least 35% alcohol. You might not have it when you need it. You perhaps prefer another flavor. Other alternatives could do the trick.

What is Vanilla Extract?

Vanilla extract is an essential ingredient in a lot of, but not limited to, Western desserts, especially in baked goods such as brownies, cakes, cupcakes, and cookies, which is the subject of discussion here. Pure vanilla extract contains several hundred additional flavor compounds responsible for its complex, deep flavor.

Vanilla extract is a liquid component made by soaking vanilla pods in a solution of alcohol (ethanol) and water. Of all forms of vanilla used today in cooking, drinking, and baking, vanilla extract is the most used form.

See also  Can You Buy Vanilla Beans at the Grocery Store?

The common amount of vanilla extract used is one teaspoon when baking cookies. For one teaspoon of vanilla extract, there are several diverse milligrams of calories, protein, carbohydrates, sugar, and fat, making it a healthy solution and a wonderful addition to your baking recipes.

Vanilla extract uses in recipes

Although this article focuses on ways to substitute vanilla extract in cookies, there are so many other uses of vanilla extract. Its deep flavor and a sweet aroma make it a viable option as a sweetening agent in baked foods and custard, puddings, ice creams, etc.

Vanilla extract substitute in cookies

Whether you’re trying to avoid the alcohol content or you prefer another option, or you can’t get a hold of vanilla extract in your cookies when you need it. Fortunately, there are other close alternatives. So let’s browse through some of them.

Vanilla paste The term paste might lead you to think about what the texture and outcome of your cookies would be like; do not fret. It is not as think as you’d think. It has the same appearance as syrup, so it is absolutely a great replacement.

Vanilla paste is a combination of the extract of vanilla, vanilla beans, and the required amount of sugar. It has a very dominant intense flavor and a smooth texture and contains the distinctive black flecks of vanilla beans. And because of its similar properties, it can be used proportionally in equal quantity as you would vanilla extract.

Vanilla powder

This is a fine and light-colored powder made of vanilla beans. It is preferred in frostings and pale cakes. It is also intense. High temperatures may cause the vanilla extract to evaporate, making a baked good less flavorful. Vanilla powder is unaffected by high heat, meaning it retains an intense flavor.

Like vanilla extract, vanilla powder is also very versatile. It gives a good result when used with cookies and other baked foods, oatmeal, cereals, coffee or chocolate, etc. It can also be used in the same ratio as vanilla extract.

Almond extract

It is common knowledge that people use almond extract in cookies. However, you can never miss the nutty flavor of almond extract because it is way stronger than vanilla extract. However, if you use too much of it, it can change the taste of your cookies to a slightly bitter taste.

Sometimes if you’re using vanilla extract in cookies and the sugar content underwhelms you, or the taste isn’t as sweet as you want it, the addition of almond extract adds a great deal more flavor, elevating these sugar cookies to your taste. Also, note that it should be used in reduced quantity because of its stronger flavor.

Marple Syrup

Pure maple syrup has a thick, sweet flavor profile, making it an excellent vanilla extract alternative. It can also add moisture and binding properties to your cookies and other baked goods. However, be careful not to use the imitation syrup though, as the flavor is quite different from vanilla extract. It can be used in the same proportion as well.

See also  Where To Find Vanilla Extract In The Grocery Store???


People usually add a bit of honey to vanilla extract in cookies, mostly likely to beef up the sweet taste and help with enhancing the aroma. It can also be used alone if you don’t have vanilla extract. It adds a bright, floral sweetness to your cookies and enhances the cookies’ texture. Using it in the same ratio would give you the perfect outcome.

When baking cookies, vanilla extract is a vital flavoring ingredient; it makes your cookies come out good with great flavor and taste. Not only that, it has numerous nutritional benefits as well. So if you want to opt for another close substitute for whatever reason, there are so many of them that you could use and still wouldn’t miss that savory flavor.

Is vanilla extract necessary for cookies?

Vanilla extract is not necessary for the structure of a baking recipe. However, but leaving it out of a recipe will change the flavor. When using vanilla extract in a recipe, you can count on it delivering the sweet flavor and aroma that makes your desserts light and delicious.

If you are replacing vanilla extract in cookies, make sure there is enough flavor as well as moistness. For example, don’t use more than 3 tablespoons for a standard recipe of about 1 pound of confectioners’ sugar.

If a recipe does not call for vanilla extract, it should still contain some form of vanilla. A recipe can be adulterated with flavoring extracts such as almond or orange oil to give a similar result without the calories or alcohol content of real vanilla extract.

Can I use honey in place of vanilla extract?

Yes, you can. Honey is a great substitute but make sure you reduce the amount of sugar in your recipe. You will need to reduce the amount of honey by ¼th of the amount of vanilla extract or alcohol. Honey also contains natural sugars, so you will not have to worry about adding any extra sugar.

My recipe calls for vanilla extract but I don’t have any; what should I use?

In a pinch, you can substitute with an equal amount of lemon juice or lime juice. The acid will break down the starch in flour and turn it into a paste that helps hold cookies together. However, this is only a temporary solution and is not recommended for most recipes. You may also wish to try a different recipe to use up the vanilla extract you are missing.

What does vanilla extract do in baking cookies?

It enhances and upgrades other flavors in the recipe. Without it, your cookies would taste flat, and you wouldn’t like it at all. Also, vanilla extract is the perfect substitute in baked goods like cakes and cookies. To get a great result in your cookies, you should use quality vanilla extract unless you are using an imitation supplement.

See also  Ten Things To Avoid In How Long Is Vanilla Extract Good For

How do I know if my vanilla extract is any good?

There are several ways to test if your vanilla extract is up to par: taste it and see if it is strong and potent, smell it and see if there are still notes of vanilla bean lingering from the bean itself, and finally test it by adding a little bit of it into sugar. If you find that your sugar has taken on a fresh vanillin flavor, then your vanilla extract is good for baking.

What can I use if I don’t have vanilla extract for cookies?

A recipe can be adulterated with flavoring extracts such as almond or orange oil to give a similar result without the calories or alcohol content of real vanilla extract.

Can I use white sugar in place of confectioners’ sugar?

This may be easy for some people because there are many who believe that white sugar is better for baking than confectioners’ sugar. However, this is not necessarily true as it would still depend on how one chooses to make their cookies. The best alternative you could try is palm sugar, which is mainly used in making Asian desserts. This can also be used in baked goods, but it needs to be coated with butter before being added into the recipe.

Can you skip vanilla extract in a recipe?

Yes, you can. This is a common practice for baking as many bakers like to skip it. Vanilla extract is not necessary for the structure of a baking recipe; however, leaving it out of a recipe will change the flavor. When using vanilla extract in recipes like pies, cakes and cookies, you often want to use this for its rich and unique flavor.

How do I make my own vanilla extract?

You can buy vanilla beans and put them in a mixture of alcohol and water or whatever liquid you choose to use. You can experiment with different ratios of sugar or salt to come up with your own personal combination that will really enhance the flavor of your vanilla extract long past simply relying on natural extracts from the bean itself.

To sum up, vanilla extract is an important component in baking cookies. Vanilla extract is used to enhance the flavor and aroma of your cookies. This is a common practice when making baked goods as many bakers like to skip it. Vanilla extract is not necessary for the structure of a baking recipe; however, leaving it out of a recipe will change the flavor. When using vanilla extract in recipes like pies, cakes and cookies, you often want to use this for its rich and unique flavor. Without vanilla extract in your recipe, your cookies would taste flat and plain and you wouldn’t like them at all.